A poem does two things at once: it says something, and it sounds a certain way. The two are hard to separate, so researchers systematically altered the and the of exactly the same stanzas and left the words in place. What changed in the response?
Both of them mattered, and not only as decoration. Participants heard the different versions of the same stanzas and rated them, and both rhyme and regular rhythm raised and emotional arousal. The researchers explain this through : an expected pattern is easier to parse, and that ease is felt as pleasure. The effect also depended on the words carrying meaning, not merely on orderly sound.
Rhyme and meter are not merely literary decoration. They turn up in children’s songs, in ritual, in slogans and in proverbs, which is to say wherever a text has to be remembered and passed from mouth to mouth. That already hints that they do something beyond sounding nice.
The difficulty is separating form from meaning, because in a real poem the two were written together. The solution was to alter the rhyme and the meter of exactly the same stanzas systematically and leave the words alone, so the difference between versions is sound rather than content.
Both rhyme and regular rhythm raised aesthetic appreciation and emotional arousal. The explanation the researchers offer is processing fluency: a predictable pattern is easier to parse, and that ease is felt as pleasure. The precision matters, since ease is no guarantee of depth or of truth.
The interesting detail is that form did not work alone. The positive feeling strengthened where the orderly sound met words that carried meaning, so rhythm over nonsense is not enough. And the limit is plain: this was recited German poetry rated immediately after listening, and other traditions and languages use rhythm differently.
wat. Rhyme and regular meter made the same units of verse sound more pleasing and more moving, especially where the words carried meaning.
wat wat
The form of a text is not neutral packaging. The ear builds an expectation, and the meeting of expectation and meaning changes the experience.
How do we know?
Participants listened to German poetic stanzas in which rhyme, meter and meaning were varied separately as far as possible, then rated liking and feeling.
What is still unknown
The study tested recited German poetry and immediate ratings; other poetic traditions and languages use rhythm differently.
Learn something?
Where to next
What does a rhyme do to the line you read four lines ago?poetry
What does the brain do differently when writing a poem and when editing one?poetry
How many different feelings can music raise without saying a word?emotion